When I was a doctoral student in Science Education in the 1990s at The Ohio State University, Vic Mayer (1933-2011) was on my committee. He was a fabulous science educator and a role model for all who were in the program. As a proponent of hands-on science, it perplexed me when he said one day, “All classroom hands-on science is a simulation of real science.” I could partially see his point: clearly many hands-on activities were simulations, especially when contrasted with having students examine real data sets that seem common in the Earth Systems sciences, which Dr. Mayer loved. Yet I wondered, why isn’t looking at cells through a microscope real science?
When it comes to air tracks and air tables for doing physics investigations, these clearly are simulations. They are also very expensive simulations with the cost of one group’s materials approaching $1000 when you factor in the track or table, air source, photogates, and other materials. So a class set of the materials can easily approach $7000. It would be great to have lab technicians keep the apparatus fine-tuned but alas that responsibility typically falls upon the physics teacher. The point of any simulation is to help students understand real concepts, such as momentum.
I was delighted to experience Adaptive Curriculum’s Activity Object “Conservation of Momentum in One Direction.” The Activity Object begins with an animation of two basketball players throwing a ball back and forth, and then being put on ice skates. Now, the players move backwards as they throw the ball forward (Newton’s Third Law). Students are now engaged by the question, why did the player on the left move more than the player on the right?

Instead of just sliding objects on an air table, the Activity Object shows clearly what each block represents in our basketball situation, as shown in the scene below. This helps students establish the real-world connection.

Then the rich scaffolding begins. First students join different orange blocks, the spring, and the red block, and set them in motion by releasing the compressed spring. Students have to examine the data for which physical property (mass or volume) is important in determining the block’s speed. The analysis of data indicates that the mass is important.
After the exploration, an explanation describes momentum, and explains the equation and units for momentum. In the elaboration phase, students now tackle the driving question of the basketball players. The students now join the orange and red blocks with a spring but also place the blue block on the table. When the blocks are launched, the orange block moves to the left, the red block to the right where it collides and joins with the blue block. Just as in the starting investigation, students see the actual motion of the blocks, so the data they explore is more meaningful. Then the momentum of each block (orange, red, and red joined with blue) is calculated, and all of these momenta are the same. This helps students to progress in their understanding of conservation of momentum.

This understanding is further developed with an animation describing conservation of momentum. Then students are introduced to other applications of Newton’s Third Law and momentum, including rocket launches, automobile-truck collisions, and Newton’s cradle. After the Activity Object, a ten-question multiple-choice evaluation helps teachers know which concepts students have mastered and where they may need additional work. There is a well-designed Enrichment Sheet for homework where students read a few paragraphs and then answer questions about momentum and solve problems.
As wise of a man as Vic Mayer was, I’m still not sure that all hands-on activities are simulations but I do know that some simulations are better, more economical, and easier than other simulations. “Conservation of Momentum in One Direction” shows the power of a virtual simulation in scaffolding and developing deep understanding of concepts, using the 5E learning model, and helping students realize how classroom science concepts apply to their lives.

I had the great opportunity to hear Jim Gee and Lee Hartwell speak about very different topics this week, at different events, but one theme they both hit on was the idea of “Find Your Passion.” For Lee it involved asking questions in science inquiry that inspire you. This Nobel Prize winning scientist told his sustainability class to find something they are passionately interested in. For Jim, it was about electronic learning through passionate interactions. He told our entire college the story of Tabby Lou and the Purple Potty.

Perhaps the greatest roll in technology for science education is helping students find their passions in science. As both men point out, fantastic things happen when passions ignite.

From social interactions to simulations to blogs, there are so many elements that can contribute to this and help students to have multiple experiences with multiple voices.

Of course, passion can also come from looking forward to a career in science and getting paid for the work they will do. Speaking of which, there are now blog sites that can link you with an advertiser to get paid for your passion, such as Link From Blog. It is great to connect passion with future earnings, but Jim Gee really makes the point, that it is not always necessary.

Especially in the winter months, I enjoy a good cup of strong, hot coffee. So I purchased the 12V and USB Travel Mug from ThreeSixty Lifestyle. It is a nice looking mug with a cover but on my first use, it didn’t seem like it really was adding any heat to the coffee.

So I got out my probeware and Spark (from Pasco) and put it to the test. First, I determined that the coffee in our coffee pot is 80° C (degrees Celsius or 176° F ).  To test the mug, I filled it almost full (350 mL) with water at about 80° C (beverage heating for 12 ounces in our microwave) without plugging into my USB. Then I dumped this out and started again and I tested it with 80° C water with it plugged in.

From the first graph, after about 80 minutes it had a temperature of 46° C. From the second graph it kept a constant temperature of 60° C after

Graph 1: Cooling Curve with No Electrical Heating

falling for the first 28 minutes. So clearly heat is being added with an equilibrium (heat lost=heat gained) established at 60° C with a room temperature of approximately 20° C. But is it worth the bother to plug it into my computer and have a tethered cup? Without heating the cup, the

Graph 2: Cooling Curve with USB Electric Heating

water stayed above 60° C for approximately 30 minutes. It seems like both cups took about the same amount of time to cool to 60° C so there is no advantage for my first cup of jo in the morning, as that usually doesn’t last 30 minutes. Later in the morning, when I tend to let the coffee sit longer, it might pay to have it plugged in. But coffee at 60° C doesn’t give me that coveted deep-warming feeling. So good thing I bought this at Big 5 Sports, as they are quite good at accepting returns.

When it comes down to it, I would like to find a coffee heater that has a

Image from "Melting and Boiling Points: Heating Curve" from Adaptive Curriculum

heating curve, rather than a cooling curve.  Perhaps I need a hot plate, like the one shown in the image from Adaptive Curriculum to the right. Bring on the heat!

Here is a hot list of the titles in this blog on science education and technology for 2010:

Ice Candle and Specific Heat, December 30, 2010

Science Prezi-tations: A Break from PowerPoints, December 22, 2010

Sounds for Science Educators, November 27, 2010

Great Science Teaching: An Iterative Process, October 25, 2010

Report To The President Prepare And Inspire: K-12 Education In Science, Technology, Engineering, And Math (Stem) For America’s Future, October 21, 2010

Engaging Starts and Video of Class, October 1, 2010

Titles for 2010 www.ed-tech-4-science.com placed into Wordle

The Context of Learning and Learning with Style, September 15, 2010

Animals in the Science Classroom, August 29, 2010

What is Science? July 31, 2010

Readers and Science Education, July 12, 2010

Electric Cars, Tesla, and Sustainability, June 28, 2010

Sports Drinks, Young Athletes, and Summer Heat, May 29, 2010

Guided Inquiry and Surface Area to Volume Ratio, May 26, 2010

Happy Earth Day, April 22, 2010

Scale of the Universe, April 10, 2010

NSTA Presentation, March 19, 2010

SMALLab Physics, March 3, 2010

My Mendel Moment and a Review of Sprout & Grow Window, February 8, 2010

Testosterone and Who We Are, January 20, 2010

Science and the Haitian Earthquake, January 18, 2010

Science Shows by Undergraduate Students, January 13, 2010

“After Armageddon” on the History Channel, January 5, 2010

When it comes to gift giving, I suspect that science teachers tend to give gifts with richer science experiences than most other people. This is sometimes but not always appreciated, so moderation is required. This Christmas, my wife was the recipient of the “Mathmos Thaw” ice candle from think-geek.com. My iphone picture to the right shows the beauty of a candle shining through about ½ inches of frozen water.

One thing that science teachers appreciate more than your everyday person is the extremely high specific heat capacity of water. The high specific heat capacity of water has great demonstrations (for example “Flaming Hands”) and all sorts of implications such as more moderate climates when living near a large body of water and why water is so good at putting out fires. Adaptive Curriculum just released a new Activity Object entitled “Specific Heat.” Through a series of virtual experiments, students are led to an understanding of the amount of heat transferred or absorbed (Q) = mass (m) x change in temperature (∆T) x specific heat (c).

This Activity Object from Adaptive Curriculum is a fantastic way to help students develop a deep understanding of concepts related to heat transfer that are important in both physics and chemistry.

* * *

Time lapse Mathmos Thaw From Think-Geek.com

“Thermodynamics is a funny subject. The first time you go through it, you don’t understand it at all. The second time you go through it, you think you understand it, except for one or two small points. The third time you go through it, you know you don’t understand it, but by that time you are so used to it, it doesn’t bother you anymore.” Arnold Sommerfeld (1868-1951) From:  http://www.eoht.info/page/Arnold+Sommerfeld

While there are many powerful tools in the science teacher’s tool chest, one of the most potent is the word processor. This is because lesson planning is an iterative process; we write what we think is an effective lesson plan, then teach it, then modify it, then teach it, then modify it, etc. Although taken for granted now, we forget how easy it is to open a file and make some modifications that enhance what we do as science teachers.

Science teachers should have a template that they use in their day-to-day lessons. A template reduces the need to re-type information on a daily basis, and a template is a reminder of important areas for the teacher to include.

I have been using a Microsoft Word template for about seven years now in my preservice teacher classes. Overtime, I have modified the template, adding sections and deleting others. On a recent assignment in my elementary science methods class, I had a lot of strong lesson plans submitted by my students. Paige Hogg wrote an excellent Parachutes, and I am attaching her lesson plan as an example of a strong lesson and the use of a lesson plan template.

This week I witnessed the possibility and perils of animals in the classroom. I was observing a fourth grade classroom as part of a grant where I RTOP the instruction. Prior to the students walking in, I looked at a couple of tanks, and saw one full of green plants in a moist environment. I looked carefully for the critters inside. The classroom teacher saw me looking and told me that unfortunately the district had turned off the air conditioning in the summer and the tree frogs had died. Same thing occurred with the snake tank on the counter to the left. How sad.

The lesson commenced and it was on tadpoles and toads. It was clear that they had been following the rapid life cycle of some tadpoles and really tiny adult toads, taken from a mud hole after an Arizona rain. Using a document camera the progress of the tadpoles and different sizes were shown. Students were asked to come up with possible reasons why the tadpoles were different in size, which was an excellent way to induce critical thinking. There is no doubt, that the students were engaged in this lesson because they had been following the progress of the real living tadpoles and the toads.

Back in 1986 I was teaching in the Bronx, and I had my Madagascan hissing roaches and a tropical fish tank. For a while, I even had a salt-water tank in my classroom. The fish and especially the roaches (this was before they became popular) were excellent for engaging the students in various life science topics. At various times, places, and levels, I have had

Our new family sulcata tortoise: Not a classroom pet.

mealworms, earthworms, crickets, and other living animals in the classroom. I haven’t been a fan of the macro size animal because of the easier care requirements of the smaller animals. Animals in a classroom do add interest, but they are also a lot of work for the teacher and they can cause problems. With school vacations and so much happening in the classroom, it is difficult to always ensure a healthy animal environment. Also, it seems interest would be best kept by having a variety of living things cycle in and out of the room. An enterprising pet store and school district could partner, so the pet shop has living organism kits that teachers could check out for one or two week periods. This would help ensue that the animals are properly cared for and that the children experience a richer segment of the Earth’s biodiversity.

References

A Guide to Using Animals in the Classroom http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/Portals/9/pdf/pub009.pdf

Animals In the Classroom? A Guide to Decision

Ask Online Guide: Animal Care for Classroom Pets http://www.njabr.org/programs/ask/guide/

Today, I am at NSTA in Philadelphia. A great city, and we have been having fabulous weather. My presentation today is on the Standards Based Science Fair. I am posting the PowerPoint for this presentation. NSTA 2010.SBSF

When it comes to science supplies, you can be sure that measuring devices such as stop watches, scales, rulers, and graduated cylinders will be useful. There is risk however in purchasing other materials, as you wonder will they work.

It all started well with my Sprout and Grow Window kits that I purchased for my elementary sciencemethods classes. They planted the generous supply of pea plant seeds that the kit provided. And in 5 of the 6 windows we had healthy germination. The plants looked neat growing up out of the thin plastic container housing the roots.

But the window idea paid no dividends. Although it was possible to see some small roots amid the very dark soil, it was disappointing how little you could actually see. I took one of the kits home to care for the plants. About one week after we started the kits, I planted the same pea plants in my home garden. Last week I took pictures of pea plants in the kit and in my garden. Our home telephone is put into each picture for scale.

Garden pea plants with phone at bottom

I know this is not a carefully controlled experiment. Nevertheless, clearly the outdoor garden plants did much better than the window indoor plants. Most people would guess that would be the case, even in a “winter” in Phoenix (where we have so far managed to avoid a seriously deadly frost). But without the benefit of being able to view the roots well, you have to wonder, why would you want to use the Sprout and Grow Window kits? So this review, gives these kits a rating of only 1 out of 4 test tubes. In other words, I don’t recommend that you purchase the product.

But it is nice that the pea plants they supplied grew so well outdoors. I have never grown peas before and I must confess I felt a connection to Gregor Mendel as I saw my plants rise up and flower. I even have pea pods starting to form. I think I will hold off on any genetic crosses for the time being but I think I might be up for a virtual experience at Adaptive Curriculum’s “Mendel’s Experiment.”

From the Activity Object "Mendel's Experiment" by Adaptive Curriculum

I had the good fortune last week of being a conference presider for Irfan Kula, a talented educational designer. His session was “I Love Symbiosis.” He emailed me his PowerPoint presentation, and I am presenting this here:  i-love-symbiosis-kula.